5 Ways to Handle Bad Tenants in Fort Myers

It can be emotionally wearing when you have a tenant that has become far less stellar than the referrals you reviewed and the information provided on their application that led you to accept them in your property. 

When facing such a difficult situation, it’s constructive to have a guide providing you with options and steps you can take to relieve the stress for everyone. So read on as we explore five ways to handle bad tenants in Fort Myers.


Eviction should be a last resort, not the first step, when dealing with bad tenants in Fort Myers. It’s important to remember that eviction is a lengthy legal process that can be stressful and expensive for both you and the tenant. Before taking such a drastic step, consider the severity of the issue. Does the tenant simply have a personality that clashes with yours, or are they causing more serious problems?

Focus on the true grounds for eviction as outlined in your lease agreement and local landlord-tenant laws. Are they consistently late or missing rent payments altogether, without any communication or attempt to rectify the situation? Have they caused damage to the property beyond normal wear and tear, or engaged in disruptive behavior that negatively impacts the neighbors or violates the terms of the lease? If the answer is no to these serious offenses, then eviction might be an overreaction. It’s always best to try and work with the tenant to find a solution before resorting to legal action.

Understanding Attitude

You’re absolutely right. In a competitive market like Fort Myers, fostering a positive relationship with your tenants can be a huge asset. While having clear expectations and enforcing lease agreements are important, understanding goes a long way. There will be times when a good tenant faces a temporary setback, like a job loss or medical issue. If they’ve been a reliable renter who takes care of the property, consider working with them. This could involve offering a temporary rent payment plan or allowing them to sublease part of the unit to help cover costs. By showing compassion, you increase your chances of retaining a responsible tenant who appreciates your understanding. In the long run, this can be much more beneficial than having to find and screen a whole new tenant, especially in a competitive market.


While breaking the rules now and again may serve you, you cannot allow tenants to believe that you’ve become slack or that there are no rules about making late payments. Bad tenants in Fort Myers tend to take a mile when you only intended to give an inch. As a result, they may become habitually late payers. While there are emergency cases where you can afford to be understanding when someone cannot pay rent, your tenants’ just not having rent isn’t a valid excuse and, if it happens enough, can cause havoc with your finances.


When dealing with problematic tenants in Cagayan de Oro, creating a thorough record of their actions is crucial. This documentation serves as vital evidence should you need to take legal action. Make a habit of putting all interactions, be it complaints, requests, or warnings, in writing. Emails, dated and signed letters, or even transcripts of recorded conversations can all be helpful. Additionally, capture video or photographic evidence of any damage they cause to the property. This could include anything from broken windows to excessive wear and tear beyond normal use. Don’t forget to keep any security camera footage that might be relevant to the situation. Finally, if repairs become necessary due to the tenant’s actions, hold onto estimates and receipts from qualified contractors. This documented trail will be essential in recouping repair costs or proving neglect in court, if the situation escalates to that point. By maintaining a detailed record, you’ll be well-positioned to address the issue effectively and protect your property investment.

Hire Professional Property Managers

When you hire professional property managers, you no longer have to try to collect rent and handle bad tenants in Fort Myers yourself. Typically, when you work with property managers, their finely honed interview skills and screening process, along with their vast network of professionals in the industry, help prevent bad tenants from ever entering your property. In addition, professional property managers like those at Core Real Estate Properties have teams on-call that can quickly handle every aspect of rental properties, from repairs to maintenance, single-family homes to large complexes, and everything in between. 

Why not work with the experienced pros at Core Real Estate Properties and let them handle your bad tenants in Fort Myers and help you avoid them moving forward. You can truly begin to enjoy your passive income when you have trusted property managers like those at Core Real Estate Properties watching over your investments. At Core Real Estate Properties, our pros are on top of the market and upcoming changes, keeping you apprised to help your portfolio stay solid and healthy. Are you ready to live out your golden years and finally enjoy the financial freedom you created with your investments? Why not reach out to the trusted team at Core Real Estate Properties and leave the property management to us. Contact Core Real Estate Properties at 239-360-3176.

Get More Real Estate Market Info... Subscribe Below!

Learn more about us and find other resources on buying investment properties with us. Like us, follow us, connect!

Access Local Florida Investment Property Deals...

Handyman Properties - Fixer Uppers - High Equity. *These are not on the MLS Available properties on the next page.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.